Why Do We Vote the Way We Do?
Public Choice, Part 2
Your vote has about a 1 in 60 million chance of deciding a presidential election.
So why did you vote?
Your vote almost never decides anything.
Economists estimated the chance one vote decides a presidential election.
- About 1 in 60 million for the average voter, in 2008
- About 1 in 10 million in the closest swing states
- Gelman, Silver and Edlin, Economic Inquiry, 2012
Except when it does.
Virginia, 2017, House District 94
- 11,608 votes to 11,608 votes
- Control of the state House hung on that seat
January 4, 2018
- Both names sealed in film canisters
- An official pulled one out of a bowl
The paradox of voting
What voting gets you
- Chance you decide it times what you gain if your side wins
- Tiny chance times anything is almost nothing
What voting costs you
- Time, gas, the line, learning the issues
- That cost is real and certain
If you only vote to change the outcome, staying home is the rational choice.
Economists call that instrumental voting. You vote to get a result.
Without looking it up, who is your state representative?
Not knowing is rational too.
Learning every issue costs hours. Your vote barely moves the result.
- So most voters stay uninformed on purpose
- Economists call that rational ignorance
Millions of people still vote, every election.
What are they getting?
Expressive Voting
You vote the way you cheer
Why do you cheer at a game?
Your cheering does not change the score
- You do it anyway, every play
- It says who you are and whose side you are on
Voting can work the same way
- You get the feeling for certain
- The outcome is out of your hands either way
Expressive voting means voting to show what you value, not to change the result.
Brennan and Lomasky built this idea in Democracy and Decision, 1993.
Close elections should pull far more people to the polls. They barely do.
As close as one can in this muddy life to a decisive rejection of the instrumental voter hypothesis.
Brennan and Lomasky, 1993, quoted in Clark and Lee, Public Choice, 2016If people voted to swing the result, turnout would jump in close races.
Feeling good is cheap at the ballot box
In a store you pay for what you choose
- Generous choices cost you real money
In a voting booth you almost never pay for your vote
- You get the warm feeling for certain
- Being wrong costs you almost nothing
Higher costs can make a policy more popular
Clark and Lee, Public Choice, 2016
- Paying more can feel more virtuous
- Your vote alone never makes you pay
New Jersey, 2013
- Voters raised the minimum wage 61 to 39
- From $7.25 to $8.25, written into the state constitution
If a policy costs more, does voting for it feel like a bigger sacrifice, or a bigger mistake?
Bootleggers and Baptists
Bans on Sunday liquor sales
- Baptists backed them for moral reasons
- Bootleggers backed them because Sunday was their best day
Bruce Yandle, 1983
- Good intentions give cover to someone's profit
- Expressive voters supply the cover
Voting like a human
Adam Martin and Adam Swisher, Public Choice, 2025
- Expressive voting is really identity voting
- Who you are beats what the policy does
Built on Vernon Smith's humanomics
- People are social first
- We vote with the groups we belong to
If your party's candidate switched sides on an issue tomorrow, would you switch with them?
Identity trumps issues.
People often pick the team first and the position second.
- That is what Martin and Swisher find in the evidence
- It makes voting look less like shopping and more like belonging
Where Do the Candidates Go?
The median voter
Line the voters up on one issue
Say, how late bars can stay open
- Early closing on the left, all night on the right
- Each voter sits at the spot they want
The median voter
- The one in the middle
- Half the voters on each side
The median voter theorem
Two candidates both want a majority
- Moving toward the middle keeps your side
- And it picks up voters in between
Both drift to the middle
- Whoever gets closest to the median voter wins
Why do candidates sound far apart in a primary and so alike in the general election?
Is it irrational to vote?
Make the case both ways.
The Myth of the Rational Voter
Bryan Caplan, 2007
Same questions, two groups
Survey of Americans and Economists on the Economy, 1996
- 1,510 members of the public
- 250 people with PhDs in economics
They did not just disagree
- The public leaned the same wrong way, again and again
Shouldn't the mistakes cancel out?
The hopeful story
- If the uninformed guess at random, their guesses cancel
- The informed voters decide the result
Caplan's answer
- The errors are not random
- They lean the same direction, so they add up
Rational irrationality
When it is cheap to believe something, even when it is wrong, it is rational to believe it.
Summary of Caplan's argumentA wrong belief about your car costs you a repair bill. A wrong belief about trade costs you nothing at the ballot box.
Which beliefs do you hold because they feel good, not because you checked?
Four biases that lean the same way
Anti-market and anti-foreign
- We underrate what markets do
- We underrate what trade with foreigners does
Make-work and pessimistic
- We underrate the gains from saving labor
- We think the economy is worse than it is
Anti-market bias
Profits look like taking
- Price spikes after a storm feel like theft
- Remember the price system week
What economists see
- High prices pull in supply
- Profit rewards serving customers
Anti-foreign bias
Buying from foreigners feels like losing
- Imports feel like jobs leaving
- Trade deficits sound like debts
What economists see
- Trade makes both sides richer
- Next week we test this on tariffs
Make-work bias
Saving labor feels like destroying jobs
- Machines, robots, and now AI
- We count jobs, not what we produce
What economists see
- Doing more with less people is what growth is
- The workers freed up make something else
Pessimistic bias
It always feels worse than it is
- Every generation thinks the country is in decline
- Bad news sticks better than good news
What economists see
- Most measures of living standards keep rising over time
Thumbs up or down.
Buying American is better for the economy than buying imports.
What share of the federal budget goes to foreign aid?
Write down a number.
The public guessed 26 percent
KFF poll, March 2025
- The average guess was about 26 percent
- The real share is about 1 percent
Only 1 in 10 got it right
- Told the real number, far fewer said we spend too much
Where the money actually goes
Social Security and Medicare
- More than a third of all federal spending in 2025
- Congressional Budget Office
Voters mostly get what they ask for
- The bad news may be what they ask for
Bad policies can win because voters want them.
Rational ignorance says voters do not know. Caplan says many think they know, and they are wrong in the same direction.
- Expressive voting makes those beliefs cheap to act on
If voters are biased, is the answer less democracy or better informed voters?
Putting it together
Your vote rarely decides anything
- So staying uninformed is rational
People vote to express who they are
- Identity and feeling good beat the policy details
Cheap beliefs lean the same way
- So the mistakes add up instead of canceling
Key Terms
Practice Questions
Question 1 of 5
All done! Score: / 5
Thanks for your attention!